News

View All News & Insights

Harris Shelton Supports Tennessee Supreme Court Ruling Bringing Clarity to Real Estate Contracts

A unanimous Tennessee Supreme Court ruling provides greater clarity for businesses negotiating earnest money deposits and other liquidated damages provisions. Harris Shelton contributed to the case through an amicus brief, bringing the real estate industry’s practical perspective to questions about how those agreements should be enforced.

The firm’s team included Emily Huseth, Mike Rafferty, Will Brantley, James Maclin, and Allison Gilbert, combining litigation experience with knowledge of real estate transactions and the risks clients face when a deal falls through.

Bringing clients’ perspectives to the court

In November 2026, the Court issued its decision in SH Nashville, LLC et al. v. FWREF Nashville Airport, LLC, reversing the Court of Appeals and upholding enforcement of an earnest money provision as liquidated damages.

The dispute involved a hotel purchase near the Nashville airport. After numerous extensions and additional deposits, the purchaser failed to close and challenged the seller’s retention of approximately $18.9 million in earnest money.

Harris Shelton represented real estate companies participating as amici curiae, or “friends of the court,” rather than the parties to the lawsuit. The brief offered legal arguments informed by clients’ experience negotiating deposits, extending closing deadlines, and managing uncertainty in commercial real estate.

The firm advocated for a presumption favoring enforcement of qualifying liquidated damages provisions and against requiring a calculation explaining the agreed amount. The Court’s conclusions align with those central positions.

What the ruling means

Liquidated damages provisions allow parties to agree in advance on compensation for a breach when actual losses would be difficult to determine.

The Court clarified that these provisions are presumed enforceable when parties expressly agree that actual damages would be difficult or impossible to ascertain and that the stipulated amount reasonably estimates those damages. The party challenging the provision bears the burden of proving it is an unenforceable penalty.

The Court also rejected a requirement that parties explain how they calculated the amount to establish that presumption. As the opinion states: “To require parties to provide a metric would be particularly illogical in situations where the reason for stipulating as to damages is that there is no reliable way to estimate damages.”

Increasing deposits in exchange for closing extensions also do not, by themselves, make a provision a penalty.

Why it matters for clients

For sellers, buyers, developers, and investors, the decision provides a clearer framework for allocating risk before a dispute arises. Sellers gain greater predictability about enforcing qualifying provisions, while buyers can better assess the consequences of agreeing to deposits and extensions.

The ruling does not make every liquidated damages clause enforceable. Contract language and the circumstances surrounding the agreement still matter.

It provides a timely opportunity to review purchase and sale agreements and extension amendments with counsel. Harris Shelton’s real estate and litigation teams can help clients evaluate those documents and understand how the decision affects their transactions.

The firm’s participation demonstrates the value of connecting courtroom advocacy with transactional experience, giving clients a voice in the development of Tennessee law that shapes their business decisions.

Related Content